Call or text 24/7 · 24-hour emergency service Plano, TX 5.0 · 54 Google reviews
Verde Roofing & Construction
Roofing materials

Malarkey vs. Owens Corning Shingles: How to Compare the Two Brands

Close-up of asphalt shingle granules

In short

Both are reputable manufacturers with Class 4 impact-rated shingles, so the better choice depends on the specific product line, color, warranty path and installer, not the logo. Malarkey builds its lines on rubberized (polymer-modified) asphalt with upcycled rubber and plastic. Owens Corning offers SBS-modified Duration FLEX and non-SBS Duration STORM for impact resistance. Compare line against line, and read each warranty.

Key takeaways

  • Both brands sell UL 2218 Class 4 shingles: Malarkey’s Vista AR, Legacy and Windsor, and Owens Corning’s Duration FLEX and Duration STORM.
  • Malarkey says its shingles use NEX polymer-modified (rubberized) asphalt with upcycled rubber and plastics and smog-reducing granules; Owens Corning’s Duration lines use its SureNail nailing strip.
  • Each brand’s best warranties depend on contractor programs and required accessories, so the same shingle can carry different coverage on different roofs.
  • Owens Corning states that hail damage is excluded from its shingle warranty; manufacturer warranties cover defects, and hail is an insurance matter for either brand.
  • Installation quality, ventilation and accessories matter more to how the roof performs than the brand on the bundle.

Your roofer has narrowed the shingle choice to Malarkey or Owens Corning, and you want to know which one is better. You have probably seen confident answers both ways online.

We install both brands, so we have no reason to push one. The honest answer is that both make good shingles, and the useful comparison is product line against product line, warranty path against warranty path. Here is how to do that, using what each manufacturer publishes.

Which is better, Malarkey or Owens Corning?

Neither, as a brand. Both are established national manufacturers, both sell architectural shingles with UL 2218 Class 4 impact ratings, and both back their shingles with limited lifetime warranties against manufacturing defects. The differences that matter sit one level down:

  • Which specific line you are comparing.
  • How the asphalt is modified and how the shingle handles Texas heat and hail.
  • What the warranty covers, and what it takes to qualify for the enhanced version.
  • Which colors are actually available in North Texas.
  • Who installs it, and how well.

If you are choosing between shingle styles first, start with our guide to architectural versus 3-tab shingles.

What product lines does each brand sell?

These are the residential lines each manufacturer lists on its own website as of this writing. Lineups change, so confirm with the current product pages.

Brand and lineTypeImpact rating (manufacturer)Notes from the manufacturer
Malarkey Highlander ARArchitecturalClass 3Rubberized asphalt, algae-resistant granules
Malarkey Vista ARArchitecturalClass 4Standard 110 mph wind warranty, 130 mph enhanced
Malarkey Legacy ScotchgardArchitecturalClass 4Scotchgard-branded algae protection
Malarkey Windsor ScotchgardDesignerClass 4Malarkey’s highest algae protection
Owens Corning Duration FLEXArchitecturalClass 4 (UL 2218)SBS polymer-modified asphalt, SureNail
Owens Corning Duration STORMArchitecturalClass 4 (UL 2218)Non-SBS, WeatherGuard technology, SureNail
Owens Corning DurationArchitecturalNot Class 4SureNail, wide color range
Owens Corning OakridgeArchitecturalNot Class 4Value architectural, 110/130 mph wind ratings
Owens Corning SupremeThree-tabNot listed60 mph wind rating

Owens Corning’s shingle page lists wind ratings up to 160 mph on its Duration lines, and its product pages tie that rating to using its required components and starter shingles on eaves and rakes. Malarkey’s Vista page lists a standard 110 mph wind warranty and a 130 mph enhanced wind warranty that depends on contractor status and accessories. Wind numbers are warranty terms with conditions, so read the fine print on both.

How do the Class 4 shingles compare?

For a DFW roof, the Class 4 comparison is usually the one that matters, because hail is the main reason roofs get replaced here. Both brands use the same UL 2218 test. Owens Corning’s explanation of it: a Class 4 shingle survives a 2-inch steel ball dropped from 20 feet, repeatedly, without cracking through.

Where they differ is how they get there:

  • Malarkey says all of its residential lines use NEX polymer-modified (rubberized) asphalt, which adds flexibility. Vista AR, Legacy and Windsor carry Class 4 ratings.
  • Owens Corning takes two routes. Duration FLEX uses SBS polymer-modified asphalt for flexibility. Duration STORM is non-SBS; Owens Corning says the polymer backing in its WeatherGuard technology helps it reach Class 4.

Flexible, rubberized shingles are often preferred in hail country because they can absorb an impact rather than fracture. That is a property both brands offer. A Class 4 rating is a pass, not a score, so one Class 4 shingle is not “more Class 4” than another. Our guide to the best shingles for Texas hail explains what the rating does and does not promise.

What about sustainability and air quality claims?

This is a real point of difference. Malarkey markets its shingles as using upcycled rubber and plastics to reduce landfill waste and 3M smog-reducing granules. On its Vista page, Malarkey estimates an average 30-square roof diverts about five tires and 3,200 plastic bags from landfills.

Owens Corning focuses its marketing elsewhere: its SureNail nailing strip on the Duration series, its color range and its system warranties. If recycled content matters to you, Malarkey makes the stronger published claim. If it does not, weigh the other factors more heavily.

For heat and energy, both brands offer reflective-granule shingles in some markets. Our guide to roof color and energy efficiency covers what reflective shingles realistically do in Texas.

How do the warranties compare?

Both manufacturers offer a standard limited lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects on their architectural shingles. Both also offer stronger coverage that depends on who installs the roof and which accessories are used:

  • Malarkey lists a Certified Pro warranty for roofs installed by Certified Pro contractors with at least three Malarkey accessories in a complete system, and a Certified Premium warranty that requires at least four accessories and includes a 25-year workmanship warranty. Pro and Premium warranties can be transferred once, with the application due within 60 days after the title transfer.
  • Owens Corning runs a contractor network with Preferred and Platinum Preferred tiers. Its contractor page says only Platinum Preferred contractors can offer its best roofing system warranty, and that listed contractors are independent businesses.

Three cautions apply to both brands:

  1. A defect warranty is not hail coverage. Owens Corning states that hail damage is excluded from its shingle warranty. Manufacturer warranties cover defects in the product; storm damage is a matter for your homeowners insurance, whichever brand you choose.
  2. The enhanced warranty must be registered. Ask who registers it and when you will receive the certificate.
  3. Workmanship is a separate promise. Get the roofer’s own workmanship warranty in writing, and do not assume a manufacturer covers installation errors unless the warranty document says so.

Do not take any contractor’s word for its certification level, including ours. Look the contractor up on the manufacturer’s own locator, and ask which warranty, by name, will be registered for your roof. Our guide to roof warranties explains how to read them.

Does one brand cost more?

Not in a way you can predict from the brand alone. Price tracks the line more than the logo: a Class 4 line from either brand costs more than a standard architectural line from either brand. Distributor pricing in DFW also moves with supply and promotions.

When you compare bids, make sure they specify:

  • The exact product line and color, not just “Malarkey” or “Owens Corning.”
  • Starter, hip and ridge, underlayment and ventilation products, by brand.
  • Which manufacturer warranty will be registered.
  • Decking, drip edge and flashing details.

Our guide on how to read a roofing estimate walks through these lines, and the roof cost calculator gives a rough range before you meet a roofer.

When does each brand make the stronger case?

Because the Class 4 lines are close on paper, the decision often comes down to one or two priorities. Here is a fair way to think about it.

Malarkey may suit you better if:

  • Recycled content and the smog-reducing granule claim matter to you.
  • You like the idea of rubberized asphalt across the whole lineup, including its non-Class 4 Highlander AR.
  • You want a designer-profile shingle with a Class 4 rating; Windsor is listed as both.
  • The installer can register a Malarkey Certified Pro or Premium warranty and you value the workmanship coverage in the Premium version.

Owens Corning may suit you better if:

  • You want to choose between two different Class 4 approaches, SBS-modified FLEX or non-SBS STORM.
  • You prefer the SureNail nailing strip on the Duration series and the wind ratings Owens Corning publishes for it.
  • A color in the Duration lineup is the one you and your HOA agree on.
  • The installer can register one of Owens Corning’s system warranties and you have checked the contractor’s tier on Owens Corning’s locator.

Either way, ask the roofer which line they install most often and why. A crew that installs a product every week tends to know its quirks, and that experience is worth more than a small spec difference.

How should I decide between the two?

A simple process works well:

  1. Decide whether you want Class 4. In DFW, many homeowners do, both for hail resistance and possible insurance discounts. Ask your agent before choosing; our guide to new roofs, home value and insurance discounts explains what to ask.
  2. Pick the matching lines. Compare Malarkey Vista AR, Legacy or Windsor against Owens Corning Duration FLEX or Duration STORM.
  3. Narrow by color. Look at full-size samples and, if possible, a finished roof nearby. Color is the most common deciding factor once performance is equal.
  4. Compare warranty paths. Which enhanced warranty can this installer register, and what does it require?
  5. Check HOA rules. Many planned communities in Frisco, McKinney, Allen and Plano approve specific colors or require submittals.
  6. Choose the installer first. A well-installed roof of either brand will outperform a poorly installed roof of the other.

When I lay out samples for a homeowner, I put both brands’ closest colors side by side in daylight on the driveway, because the same name can look different on a north-facing slope.

What matters more than the brand?

Installation and the parts you do not see. Nailing pattern, starter course, underlayment, flashing and attic ventilation decide whether a roof lasts. Ask the roofer how each manufacturer’s installation requirements, including ventilation, will be met on your roof, and get that in the scope. Before you sign, use our list of questions to ask a roofer to check the installer as carefully as the shingle.

Want to see both brands on your house?

Chris can bring Malarkey and Owens Corning samples, inspect your roof with you, and explain the trade-offs line by line. Learn more about our roof replacement service, then call or text (214) 687-1951 (24/7) or book a free roof inspection.

Questions people ask next

Is a Class 4 shingle from one brand stronger than the other’s?

Not in any way the rating can show. UL 2218 Class 4 is a pass at the highest test level, not a score, so two Class 4 shingles both survived the same steel-ball test. Real-world differences come from the asphalt formulation, how the shingle ages in heat, and installation. Compare product data sheets and talk to your insurer about discounts.

Will my insurance discount be the same for either brand?

Ask your agent before you choose. Owens Corning notes that many insurers offer discounts for Class 4 shingles, and both brands sell Class 4 lines, so the question is whether your carrier ties the discount to the rating or to a product list. Also ask which documents they need and whether the discount changes how cosmetic hail damage is covered.

Can I mix Malarkey shingles with Owens Corning accessories?

The roof can be built that way, but you may lose the enhanced warranty. Both manufacturers tie their stronger warranties to a system of their own starter, hip and ridge, underlayment and ventilation products. If the enhanced coverage matters to you, ask the roofer to list every accessory brand on the estimate.

Which brand has more colors available in Dallas?

Color availability changes by region and by product line, and both manufacturers note that not every color is stocked everywhere. The practical step is to pick two or three colors you like from each brand’s current Texas lineup, then ask the roofer to confirm local supply and show you a full-size sample or an actual roof nearby.

Does the shingle brand affect resale value?

Buyers and inspectors care more about the roof’s age, condition and paperwork than the logo. A transferable warranty, the installation invoice and the product’s impact rating are what help at sale time. Keep those documents together and check each manufacturer’s transfer rules; Malarkey, for example, sets its deadline in days after the title transfer.

Sources

  1. Malarkey Roofing Products: Residential shingles
  2. Malarkey Roofing Products: Vista shingle
  3. Malarkey Roofing Products: Warranties
  4. Owens Corning: Roofing shingles
  5. Owens Corning: Find a roofing contractor (Preferred and Platinum Preferred)
  6. Owens Corning: Class 4 impact-resistant roofing shingles
About the author

Chris Grimes owns Verde Roofing in Plano, Texas, a locally owned residential and commercial roofer serving Dallas–Fort Worth. Verde is an NTRCA Accredited Member, an RCAT member and a Dallas Observer Best of Dallas Best Roofer winner (readers’ choice) in 2021, 2022 and 2023.

Related serviceRoof Replacement in Plano & DFW
CallText