Two Very Different Roof Quotes in Allen? How to Get a Third

In short
Verde Roofing, a locally owned roofer based in Plano, gives free roof inspections and written estimates in Allen, the next city north of its office. Owner Chris Grimes inspects with you and photographs what he finds; call or text (214) 687-1951 24/7. Verde is an NTRCA Accredited Member with a 5.0 rating from 54 Google reviews. Whoever you ask, give them a written scope so the third quote matches the first two.
Key takeaways
- Two quotes for one roof usually differ because they describe two different jobs, not because one roofer is cheap and the other greedy.
- The biggest hidden gaps are measured squares, waste factor, decking allowance, shingle line, and whether flashing and vents are new or reused.
- This Old House puts labor at about 60 percent of a shingle roof's cost, so a much lower quote usually means fewer labor hours or fewer items.
- A one-page written scope handed to a third roofer produces a quote you can compare line by line with the first two.
- The Texas Department of Insurance advises comparing several bids to spot prices that are too high or too good to be true.
One roofer walked your Allen house and quoted a number. A second one came out and quoted something thousands of dollars away from it. Same roof, same week, and now you trust neither.
A third quote helps only if it is built to be compared. Otherwise you end up with three numbers instead of two and no better idea which is right. Here is why the first two disagree, how to turn them into a fair comparison, and who to ask for the tiebreaker.
Is a big gap between two roof quotes normal?
Yes, and published price data shows how wide the honest range is. This Old House's 2026 shingle roof guide puts asphalt shingles at $3.44 to $12 per square foot installed. Fixr's 2026 guide says most roof replacements land between $7,500 and $14,000 nationally. Those are national figures, not Verde's prices, but they make the point: the top of the normal range is several times the bottom.
That spread exists because "a new roof" is not one product. It is a measured area, a shingle line, a stack of layers under the shingles, a set of metal details, a tear-off, a disposal bill and a crew's time. Two roofers can look at one house and price two different combinations of those.
So before asking which quote is right, ask a different question: are these quotes for the same job?
Where do the differences between two quotes usually hide?
Lay both quotes on the table and go through this list. In most cases the gap is explained by three or four of these rows.
| Where quotes differ | What to look for | Question to ask each roofer |
|---|---|---|
| Roof size | Total squares and waste percentage | How did you measure, and what waste factor did you use? |
| Tear-off | Number of existing layers assumed | Did you check for a second layer? |
| Decking | Allowance included, or price per sheet, or silence | What happens if you find rotten decking? |
| Shingle | Brand, line and impact rating | Which exact product is this price for? |
| Underlayment | Felt or synthetic; any ice and water membrane in valleys | What goes under the shingles, and where? |
| Flashing and metal | New or reused step flashing, counterflashing, drip edge | Which metal is new and which stays? |
| Vents and pipe boots | Replaced, reused or not mentioned | Are all boots and vents new? |
| Ridge and starter | Purpose-made ridge cap and starter, or cut 3-tab | What product is on the ridge and the eave? |
| Permit and code items | Included, excluded or not mentioned | Who pulls the permit, and is the fee in the price? |
| Warranty | Workmanship term in writing; manufacturer coverage level | Can I see both warranties before I sign? |
| Basis of the price | Insurance scope or retail cash price | Is this priced to my insurer's estimate or independent of it? |
A few of these deserve a closer look.
Squares and waste
Roofers price by the square, which is 100 square feet of roof surface. Owens Corning's measuring guide recommends adding 10 to 15 percent for waste and more on complicated roofs. On a roof that measures 30 squares, the two ends of that range come to 33 and 34.5 squares before anyone has done anything wrong. If one quote says 31 squares and the other 38, somebody measured differently, and you need to know who. Our guide to roofing squares shows how to check.
Decking
Nobody can see the decking until the old roof is off. One roofer includes an allowance for a few sheets, another lists a per-sheet price, and a third says nothing and leaves it to a change order. Fixr puts decking replacement at $2 to $8 per square foot, so silence on this line can be expensive later.
Reused versus new
Reusing flashing, vents and drip edge saves the roofer real money, and it rarely appears as a line that says "reused". It appears as a line that is missing. Our guide to underlayment, ventilation and decking explains why those hidden parts matter.
Is the low quote a bargain, or is the high quote padded?
Either is possible. The structure of roofing costs tells you where to look.
This Old House says labor is about 60 percent of a roof's total cost, and Fixr puts it at 40 to 60 percent. Two roofers buying the same shingle line pay broadly similar material prices. So a quote that is far below the other usually differs in labor hours, in the items covered, or in the grade of material, not in some secret discount.
Signs the low quote is thin:
- Lines that the other quote has are simply absent.
- The shingle is named by brand only, with no product line.
- No mention of decking, permit or cleanup.
- A large deposit is requested. The Texas Department of Insurance tells homeowners not to pay in full up front.
Signs the high quote is carrying extra:
- More squares than the roof plausibly has.
- Upgrades you did not ask for, such as a premium shingle line or full-roof membrane.
- Lump sums ("roof system, complete") with no breakdown.
- A price that drops sharply the moment you hesitate.
Neither list proves bad faith. A high quote may simply include a better shingle and all-new metal, which is a choice you are allowed to make on purpose.
How do you write a scope so the third quote is comparable?
This is the step that makes a third quote worth getting. Instead of asking a third roofer "what would you charge?", hand them a one-page scope and ask them to price it, then tell you what they would change and why.
- Take the longer of your two quotes as the starting list. Copy every item onto one page, without prices.
- Add anything the shorter quote has that the longer one lacks.
- Fix the product. Write the shingle brand, line and color family you actually want, or write "price both of these lines".
- State the layers. "Tear off one layer" or "tear off two layers", based on what the roofers found.
- Ask for decking as a unit price. "Price per sheet of decking replaced, with photos of any sheet replaced."
- List the metal as new. Drip edge, step flashing, pipe boots, vents. If a roofer wants to reuse something, they can say so and show the credit.
- Ask for the measurement. Total squares, waste percentage and how it was measured.
- Ask for the permit, haul-off and cleanup to be listed as lines.
- Ask for both warranties in writing.
- Leave room for disagreement. End with: "If your inspection finds something this scope misses, add it as a separate line with a photo."
That last line matters. A good third roofer may find something both earlier quotes missed, and you want to hear it without losing the comparison.
For the meaning of each line, our guide to reading a roofing estimate line by line goes item by item, and the roof cost calculator gives a published-range ballpark to sanity-check all three.
Who should you ask for the third quote in Allen?
Pick the third roofer for what the first two did not give you: evidence.
- Someone who inspects before pricing. A quote written from a satellite image and a drive-by cannot tell you about soft decking, a second layer or failed flashing.
- Someone who shows photos. You should see the roof conditions that justify each line.
- Someone with a street address you can verify in North Texas. Allen sits in Collin County between Plano and McKinney, and after hail the area draws crews from far away. See how to spot a storm chaser.
- Someone whose memberships can be checked. Texas has no state roofing license, so trade association membership, proof of insurance and reviews do the work a license would. Our guide to choosing a roofer in DFW lists what to verify.
- Someone who will price your scope, not replace it. A roofer who refuses to quote a written scope is telling you how the job will go.
Verde Roofing is one option that fits. It is locally owned, its only office is at 5055 W Park Blvd in Plano, directly south of Allen, and it serves Collin County along with ten other counties.
Also ask whether the work needs a City of Allen permit and who obtains it. Permit rules are set city by city in Texas, so confirm the current requirement with the city's building department rather than taking any roofer's word, ours included.
What changes if insurance is paying for the roof?
Then the two quotes may differ for a reason that has nothing to do with the roofers: one priced the job to your insurer's scope of loss and the other priced it as a retail job.
On a covered claim, the insurer's estimate defines what is paid. A roofer's quote that is higher than that estimate is not automatically padding; it may include items the adjuster missed, which the roofer can document and you can submit to your insurer. Our guide to roof insurance supplements explains how that works. You own the claim, and a contractor cannot act as your public adjuster.
Two Texas rules apply to every quote on an insurance job. Under Business and Commerce Code §27.02, a contractor may not pay, waive, absorb or rebate your deductible, and a contract of $1,000 or more expected to be paid from a claim must carry a bold notice saying you must pay it. The Texas Department of Insurance says violators face up to a $2,000 fine and up to six months in jail.
So if one quote is lower because the roofer has offered to "cover" the deductible, it is not a lower quote. It is an illegal one.
When do you not need a third quote?
Sometimes the work of lining up the first two answers the question.
- The gap closes once the scopes match. If adding the missing lines to the low quote brings it within a few percent of the high one, pick the roofer you trust more.
- One roofer cannot explain their own quote. If they cannot say how they measured or what the shingle line is, you have your answer.
- The roof may not need replacing. If only one of the two recommended a full replacement, you do not need a third price. You need a documented opinion on the roof itself. See repair or replace your roof, or getting a second opinion before you replace a roof.
How does Verde Roofing put together a quote?
Chris Grimes, the owner, inspects the roof with you and photographs what he finds, including the attic when it is reachable. If a repair would carry the roof, he says so. If a roof replacement is the better use of your money, you get a written estimate after that free inspection. We do not give prices over the phone, because the price depends on what the roof actually needs.
Bring your scope page, or bring both quotes with the prices covered. When I price against someone else's scope, I start by measuring the roof myself, because every other number on the page is multiplied by the squares.
Verde installs Malarkey and Owens Corning shingles, is an NTRCA Accredited Member and an RCAT member, was voted Best Roofer in the Dallas Observer's Best of Dallas readers' choice in 2021, 2022 and 2023, and holds a 5.0 rating from 54 Google reviews. Ask us, like any roofer, for the manufacturer and workmanship warranties in writing.
Get a third quote you can compare
Call or text (214) 687-1951, 24/7, or book a free roof inspection. Tell us you already have two quotes for your Allen home, and we will inspect the roof, show you the photos and give you a written estimate you can set beside the other two.
Questions people ask next
Is it rude to show a roofer the other quotes I received?
No, but share the scope rather than the prices. If a roofer sees a competitor's total first, you learn what they are willing to match, not what they would have charged. Hand over the list of materials, quantities and items you want priced, keep the dollar figures to yourself, and compare once the third quote arrives.
How many roof quotes should I get in Allen?
The Texas Department of Insurance advises getting more than one bid, and three is a practical number for a full replacement. Past that, the returns shrink quickly. Three quotes written to the same scope tell you more than six quotes that each describe a different job. Spend the extra effort on making them comparable instead.
Should I just take the middle quote?
Only if it is also the most complete. The middle price is not automatically the fair one; it may be a thin scope with a healthy margin or a thorough scope priced tightly. Line the three up by item. The right quote is the one that covers what your roof needs, from a roofer whose inspection findings you can verify with photos.
Can a roofer lower the price if I ask?
Sometimes, and the honest ways are visible on paper: a different shingle line, reusing sound counterflashing, or scheduling flexibility. Be wary when the price drops sharply with no change to the scope, because the cost comes out of labor or materials you cannot see. On an insurance job, any discount tied to your deductible is illegal in Texas.
Why did one roofer measure my roof much larger than the other?
Common reasons are a different waste factor, one roofer measuring from satellite imagery and the other by hand, or one including a patio cover or detached structure the other skipped. Ask each to show the measurement report and the waste percentage. A difference of a square or two is normal; a bigger gap needs an explanation.
Sources
- Fixr: How Much Does a Roof Replacement Cost? (2026)
- This Old House: Shingle Roof Cost Guide (2026)
- Owens Corning: DIY Roofing Calculator and Measuring Guide
- Texas Department of Insurance: State law cracks down on roof scams
- Texas Department of Insurance: After hail or windstorms
- Texas Business and Commerce Code §27.02
Keep reading
Related guides
Cost & financingHow to Read a Roofing Estimate Line by LineA complete roofing estimate lists the company’s full contact details, the measured squares and waste factor, how many layers come off, the exact shingle line, underlayment…Read the guide
Roofers by cityGetting a Second Opinion Before You Replace a Roof in DallasYes, you can get a second opinion before replacing a roof in Dallas. Verde Roofing, a locally owned roofer based in Plano, gives free inspections there…Read the guide
Cost & financingWhat Is a Roofing Square? How Roofers Measure and Price Your RoofA roofing square is 100 square feet of roof surface. Roofers measure every roof plane, multiply length by width, add the planes together, adjust for pitch…Read the guide 

