Should You Call a Roofer or Your Insurance Company First?

In short
If water is coming in, protect the home first and tell your insurer promptly. If the roof is not leaking, most Texas homeowners are better off getting a free inspection from a reputable local roofer before filing, so they know whether the damage is real and worth more than the deductible. Texas law says a general coverage question to your insurer is not a claim.
Key takeaways
- An active leak comes first: stop the water, photograph it and report the damage promptly.
- Without a leak, an inspection before filing tells you whether you have storm damage and whether it likely exceeds your deductible.
- Under Texas Insurance Code §551.113, an insurer may not use a general customer inquiry to decline, cancel or nonrenew a policy.
- TDI says temporary repairs are generally fine, but permanent repairs should wait until you have talked to your insurer.
- Your policy sets the reporting deadlines; read the conditions section rather than relying on a rule of thumb.
The storm has passed, and you are standing in the driveway looking at shingle pieces in the yard or a dented gutter. Your neighbor says to call the insurance company right away. A flyer on your door says to call a roofer. You want to do this in the right order, without hurting your claim or your policy.
There is a sensible order, and it depends mostly on one question: is water getting into the house right now? This guide walks through both situations and the Texas rules that shape the decision.
Who should you call first after storm damage?
Here is the short version:
| Your situation | Call first | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Water is coming through the ceiling or the roof is open | Stop the water, then call your insurer and a roofer the same day | You have a duty to protect the home, and the loss is clearly real |
| A tree or large limb is on the roof | 911 if anyone is hurt or lines are down; then a roofer for tarping and your insurer | Safety and structural risk come before paperwork |
| Hail or wind hit, but nothing is leaking | A reputable local roofer for a free inspection | You learn whether there is real damage before you file |
| You are not sure anything happened | A roofer inspection, or simply watch for leaks | Many storms leave no roof damage at all |
| You already know the damage is large and covered | Your insurer, then a roofer | Starting the claim early starts the insurer's clock |
Most homeowners after a DFW hailstorm fall into the third row. For them, an inspection first usually makes the most sense.
Why get a roof inspection before filing a claim?
Because a claim is a decision, and you make better decisions with facts. An inspection answers three questions:
- Is there storm damage at all? Granule loss, blistering and cracking from age are not hail damage. Many roofs in older Dallas neighborhoods show wear that looks alarming but is not storm-related. TDI notes that insurance will not pay for a new roof just because it is old or worn out.
- How much damage is there? A few creased shingles on one slope is a different situation from hail hits across every slope.
- Is it likely to cost more than your deductible? Many Texas policies carry a separate wind and hail deductible. TDI notes it is often higher than the deductible for other damage. If the repair costs less than the deductible, a claim pays you nothing.
On our storm calls, Chris inspects the roof with you, documents what he finds with photos and explains repair versus replacement before any claim is filed. Sometimes the honest answer is that the roof is fine, or that the damage is a small repair you are better off paying for directly.
Our guide to signs of hail damage on a roof shows what real hail damage looks like and what it does not.
Does asking your insurer a question count as a claim in Texas?
Not if it is a general question. Texas Insurance Code §551.113 says an insurer may not consider a "customer inquiry" as a basis to decline, cancel or nonrenew a homeowners policy. The statute defines a customer inquiry as a call or other communication about the general terms, conditions or coverage of the policy that does not result in an investigation or claim. It includes questions about how to file a claim and whether a policy will cover a loss.
There is an important limit. The protection does not apply if the question concerns specific damage that has occurred and results in an investigation or claim. So asking "Does my policy have a separate hail deductible, and how much is it?" is an inquiry. Calling to report that hail damaged your roof on a specific date is likely to start a claim.
That gives you a practical path: ask your agent general questions about your deductible, coverage type and exclusions, get a roof inspection, then decide whether to report.
When should you call your insurance company first?
Call your insurer first, or right after stopping the water, when:
- Water is entering the home, or the roof is open to the weather
- A tree or limb has broken through the roof or damaged the structure
- Interior damage is obvious: wet insulation, stained or sagging ceilings, damaged contents
- You may need to leave the home while repairs are made
- Your city or HOA has a widespread storm and you already know your roof took serious hits
In these cases, the loss is plainly real and delay does not help you. Report it, write down the claim number and the name of the person you spoke with, and keep a log of every contact.
What can you do to the roof before the adjuster comes?
Protect it, but do not rebuild it. TDI's guidance says it is generally fine to make temporary repairs, and that you should not make permanent repairs until you have talked to your insurer. Photograph the damage before any work starts and keep receipts. Temporary work usually means:
- A properly fastened tarp over open or leaking areas
- Moving belongings away from leaks and catching water
- Removing standing water and wet materials that will grow mold
- Boarding a broken skylight or window
Permanent work, such as replacing shingles, decking or a full slope, should wait until the insurer has seen the damage or agreed you can proceed. For what a proper tarp job looks like, see emergency roof tarping.
How do you pick the roofer to call after a storm?
After every major DFW storm, out-of-town crews and door knockers flood neighborhoods from Frisco to Rockwall. The roofer you call first will be on your roof, taking photos of your damage, and possibly standing beside your adjuster. Choose carefully.
A short checklist:
- A local address you can visit, and a phone number that is answered
- References and reviews from homeowners in your area, not just out-of-town jobs
- A written inspection with photos you get to keep
- No request to sign anything on the first visit
- No offer to cover, waive or rebate your deductible, which is illegal in Texas
- No promise to deal with your insurer for you, negotiate a settlement or speak for you on coverage
That last point is Texas law. Under Texas Insurance Code §4102.163, a contractor may not act as a public adjuster or advertise to adjust claims on property where it does or may do the work. TDI's guidance tells contractors not to offer to negotiate claim settlements or to imply they represent the policyholder. A roofer who promises that is telling you something about how it operates.
More on this in storm chasers: how to spot a roofing scam after a Texas storm and how to choose a roofer in DFW.
Is there a deadline to file a roof claim in Texas?
Your policy sets it. Most homeowners policies require prompt notice of a loss and include a time limit for reporting, and the wording varies from company to company. Read the conditions section of your policy, or ask your agent, which is a general inquiry.
Practically, sooner is better even when the policy allows more time. Fresh hail marks are easier to see and to tie to a specific storm, and interior damage from a slow leak gets worse each time it rains. Our guide on how long you have to file a roof claim in Texas covers the details.
Once you do file, the insurer's own deadlines start. TDI says the company has 15 business days to acknowledge the claim and 15 business days after receiving everything it needs to accept or reject it.
A simple order of operations
Here is what we suggest to most homeowners after hail or wind:
- Check for leaks inside: ceilings, attic, around skylights and chimneys.
- If water is coming in, protect the home and report the loss.
- If not, photograph the outside from the ground: gutters, downspouts, AC units, window screens, fences.
- Look up your wind and hail deductible and whether your roof is covered at replacement cost or actual cash value.
- Schedule a free inspection with a local, reputable roofer.
- Review the photos and the findings with the roofer before deciding.
- If the damage is real and likely above your deductible, report the claim and note the claim number.
- Schedule the adjuster visit and, if you want, ask your roofer to be there to show the damage it found.
When I inspect after a storm, I photograph the soft metal first: gutters, vents and window wraps. If they are untouched, the shingles rarely tell a different story, and I would rather tell a homeowner that than see them file a claim that goes nowhere.
For the full path after you file, read how a roof insurance claim works in Texas.
What Verde does, and what it does not
We inspect the roof with you, document the damage with photos, explain repair versus replacement before you file, meet the adjuster on site to show what we found, write the repair estimate and do the work. You own the claim and every decision on it. See our insurance claims page and our storm and hail damage page for more, or read what homeowners say in our reviews.
Get the facts before you file
If a storm hit your home and you are not sure whether to file, call or text (214) 687-1951, 24/7, or book a free roof inspection. Chris will look at the roof with you and tell you plainly what he sees, whether that points to a claim or not.
Questions people ask next
Does calling my insurance company to ask a question count as a claim?
Not if it is a general question. Texas Insurance Code §551.113 defines a customer inquiry as a call about policy terms or coverage that does not result in an investigation or claim, including how to file and whether a loss would be covered. An insurer may not use that inquiry to decline, cancel or nonrenew. Describing specific damage that leads to a claim is different.
Will filing a claim that gets denied still go on my record?
It can show up in your claims history even if nothing is paid, and how insurers use that history varies. That is one reason to get an inspection first: if the roof shows wear rather than storm damage, you may decide not to file. Ask your agent how your company treats claims that close without payment.
How soon after a hailstorm do I need to report the damage?
Your policy decides. Most policies require prompt notice of a loss and set a time limit for reporting, and the wording varies by company. Read the conditions section of your policy. Waiting can also make it harder to tie damage to a specific storm, so it is wise to have the roof checked within days or weeks, not months.
Is a free roof inspection really free, or is there a catch?
A legitimate free inspection should come with no obligation and no signature required. Be cautious of anyone who asks you to sign a contract or an authorization on the spot, offers to cover your deductible, or says they will deal with your insurance company for you. Those are warning signs under Texas law.
What if my insurer sends an adjuster before I have a roofer look at it?
That is fine. Let the adjuster inspect and ask for a copy of the estimate. You can still have a roofer inspect afterward and compare. If the roofer finds damage the adjuster missed, send the photos and estimate to your insurer in writing and ask for a re-inspection. You can also have the roofer present if the adjuster returns.
Sources
- Texas Insurance Code §551.113: Customer inquiry
- Texas Department of Insurance: Home damaged? FAQ
- Texas Department of Insurance: Getting your insurance claim paid
- Texas Department of Insurance: Roofing and insurance, know the law
- Texas Department of Insurance: State law cracks down on roof scams
- Texas Department of Insurance: Replacing your roof
Keep reading
Related guides
Insurance claimsHow a Roof Insurance Claim Works in Texas, Step by StepA Texas roof claim runs in order: protect the home, get the roof inspected and documented, report the claim, meet the adjuster, receive the insurer's decision…Read the guide
Hail & storm damageWhat to Do After a Hailstorm: The First 72 HoursAfter a hailstorm, wait until the storm has fully passed, then check for leaks and stop water from spreading. Photograph damage outside and inside before anything…Read the guide
Hail & storm damageStorm Chasers: How to Spot a Roofing Scam After a Texas StormA storm chaser follows hail from city to city, knocks on doors, pushes you to sign that day, and is hard to find once the roof…Read the guide 

